YouGov BrandIndex: Balea overtakes Nivea on customer satisfaction

Fresh analysis suggests that an inexpensive chemist own-brand is edging past a long-established giant.

For decades, Nivea has been a fixture in German bathrooms, standing for skincare, trust and reliability. But in the direct verdict of shoppers, the heritage brand has now lost its top spot. A chemist’s own label, Balea from dm, is currently posting higher satisfaction scores in a well-known brand ranking - with clear implications for the balance of power on the skincare shelf.

Balea overtakes Nivea on customer satisfaction

The shift is based on the YouGov BrandIndex, an ongoing brand-tracking study using large samples. On the measure of customer satisfaction, Balea is now clearly ahead of Nivea. Balea’s net score stands at 65,3 points, while Nivea reaches 61,8 points.

Nivea, a long-time favourite, has slipped into the role of chaser on satisfaction - Balea has moved into the lead.

What makes the figures particularly striking is the recent history: in 2021, the picture was reversed. Back then, the same analysis had Nivea 1,6 points ahead of Balea. In just a few years, the relationship has flipped completely.

For many industry watchers, this reflects a broader movement rather than a one-off: private labels - the own brands of major retailers - are increasingly pushing into categories once dominated by classic brands. What used to be seen mainly as a budget substitute is now, in many cases, becoming the first choice.

From budget buy to favourite brand

In personal care in particular, a quiet image shift is under way. For a long time Balea was mostly present on shelves as the low-cost option. Now the brand feels more self-contained and distinctive: colourful, packed with limited editions, and boosted by influencer-driven moments on social media.

That change shows up in everyday purchasing decisions. Many customers pick Balea shower gels, creams or serums even when pricier branded products are sitting right next to them. Price matters - but it is not the only selling point.

• Balea scores with a varied range
• Trend products such as hyaluronic serums or niacinamide creams appear on shelves quickly
• Packaging and product names particularly appeal to younger audiences
• Products sit in direct sightline beside significantly more expensive brands

As a result, Balea becomes an “everyday favourite brand” for many people. Once someone is happy, they often stick with it - even if the logo is not backed by a glossy advertising campaign, but comes from the local chemist chain around the corner.

Why losing top spot hurts Nivea

Nivea remains an exceptionally strong brand in most people’s minds. Precisely for that reason, losing the lead on customer satisfaction is a sensitive blow for the traditional company. Satisfaction is closely linked to loyalty: those who are very satisfied are more likely to stay faithful and recommend the brand more often.

Notably, Nivea still sits well ahead of Balea on perceived quality. In the BrandIndex quality dimension, Nivea scores 55,0 points and Balea 42,5 points. Many people therefore continue to associate Nivea with higher product quality.

Nivea’s classic brand strength is currently no longer enough to hold the number-one spot for satisfaction - the competition is tightening.

This illustrates a familiar tension in brand management: quality may be recognised, but it is not enough on its own when a cheaper brand generates more enthusiasm through its pricing, product experience and day-to-day usefulness.

Value for money as the chemist brand’s trump card

A key driver behind Balea’s rise is value for money. In this BrandIndex category, the gap has actually widened in recent years. At present, Balea achieves 42,7 points here, while Nivea manages only 31,1 points.

Crucially, a strong value-for-money rating at YouGov does not simply mean “cheap”. Respondents judge whether a brand’s performance feels consistent and fair given its price. This is exactly where a well-run own brand can excel.

Many shoppers feel they are getting an “honest deal” with Balea: modern formulas, colourful design, a pleasant feel in use - at a price that is often significantly lower than branded alternatives. Nivea benefits from its mass-market position, but this effect appears less pronounced for the brand.

Awareness remains Nivea’s strongest weapon

Despite the new order on satisfaction, the market has not completely turned upside down. Nivea continues to be a heavyweight with huge reach. According to the latest figures, 92,1% of respondents know the brand. Balea comes in at 76,9% - strong, but still clearly lower.

The purchase-intent figures among people who know the brand are particularly telling. Here, Balea edges ahead with 23,3%, compared with Nivea at 21%. Put simply: those familiar with Balea tend to choose it relatively often in practice.

The more people who become familiar with Balea, the more the brand grows in everyday life - despite lower overall awareness.

For Nivea, this creates a strategic dilemma. The brand enjoys enormous visibility, but it is losing some momentum against competitors that move quickly and compete aggressively on price.

What the YouGov BrandIndex actually measures

To interpret the numbers properly, it helps to look briefly at the method. The YouGov BrandIndex is built on daily online surveys, which roll up into continuously updated brand metrics. The index covers several dimensions:

• general impression
• perceived quality
• customer satisfaction
• willingness to recommend
• value for money
• employer image

Over long periods, this produces very large datasets. For the 2026 value-for-money ranking, the institute says that more than 900.000 interviews were included. The scores show how consumers perceive brands - but they are not a substitute for lab testing of ingredients or objective effectiveness studies.

This matters particularly in the comparison between a skincare classic and a chemist own brand: people are rating their feeling about the brand, not necessarily analysing every individual INCI list on the back of the bottle.

Nivea remains strong, but is losing pace

Even with the dip in satisfaction, Nivea is nowhere near a collapse. In rankings of general popularity, the brand still sits very high. In a recent comparison, Nivea lands on 89,1 points, only just behind Florena - a sign that underlying goodwill remains substantial.

The real issue is less about the absolute level and more about the speed of change. Cheaper brands or those with a newer positioning are gaining ground faster, while established names like Nivea cannot always match the tempo. Price-conscious groups in particular switch more readily to alternatives when those alternatives send the right signals on design, trend themes and price.

What this means for consumers

For shoppers, the current development mainly brings one thing: more choice at a high standard. Where it once felt like a decision between an “expensive brand” and a “no-name bargain cream”, private labels and heritage manufacturers are now in a genuine head-to-head race.

When buying, a few rules of thumb can help:

• Pay attention to your own skin’s needs: dry, sensitive or oily skin reacts differently.
• Compare ingredients: tolerability and the effect you want matter more than the brand name.
• Weigh up value for money: more expensive does not automatically mean better - but extremely cheap is not always sensible either.
• Test consistently: use one product for several weeks rather than constantly switching.

Budget-focused households in particular benefit from stronger own brands. Anyone looking for a well-tolerated basic moisturiser, for example, can now often find one for just a few euros. For specialist care - such as very dry skin or specific skin problems - many still continue to choose established brands with a long dermatological heritage.

What “customer satisfaction” covers in practice

The phrase customer satisfaction can sound abstract, but in everyday life it touches very practical details. In surveys, the following aspects are typically reflected:

Aspect	Example in daily skincare
Application	Does the cream absorb quickly, or does it feel sticky?
Scent	Is the fragrance pleasant, too strong, or artificial?
Skin feel	Does skin feel soft, or tight after applying?
Tolerability	Is there redness, spots, or stinging?
Price perception	Does the result match the money you have paid?

Especially with fragrances and textures, brands can differ widely. The typical Nivea scent, for instance, brings back childhood memories for many people, while others find it too intense. Chemist brands such as Balea play with a wide range of fragrances and lighter textures that particularly appeal to younger buyers.

Anyone switching between the brands quickly notices: there is no single “best” cream for everyone. What matters is what suits your own skin, your routine and your budget.

---